What is the difference between gas logs and a gas insert?

Gas logs and gas inserts are both popular options for converting traditional wood-burning fireplaces to gas-burning alternatives, offering convenience, efficiency, and aesthetics. However, they differ in design, installation method, and functionality. Here’s a breakdown of the differences between gas logs and gas inserts:

  1. Design and Appearance:
    • Gas Logs: Gas logs are artificial logs designed to mimic the appearance of real wood logs. They are typically made from ceramic or refractory materials and are placed directly into an existing wood-burning fireplace. Gas logs provide a realistic flame pattern and are available in various styles and sizes to resemble different types of wood.
    • Gas Inserts: Gas inserts are self-contained heating units that are installed into the firebox of an existing wood-burning fireplace. They consist of a metal firebox housing a gas burner, logs, and a heat exchanger. Gas inserts often feature realistic ceramic logs, glass doors, and decorative fronts, providing a more integrated and finished look compared to gas logs.
  2. Installation:
    • Gas Logs: Installing gas logs is relatively straightforward and does not require major modifications to the existing fireplace. The logs are placed directly onto the fireplace floor or on a burner grate, with gas lines connected to provide fuel for the flames. Gas logs can be installed in both vented and vent-free configurations, depending on the fireplace setup and local building codes.
    • Gas Inserts: Installing a gas insert involves more extensive modifications to the fireplace opening to accommodate the insert unit. The existing fireplace damper is typically removed or sealed, and the insert is installed securely within the firebox. Gas inserts require a properly sized chimney or venting system to exhaust combustion byproducts safely. They are available in vented and direct vent configurations, with the latter drawing combustion air from outside the home.
  3. Heating Efficiency:
    • Gas Logs: Gas logs are primarily decorative and provide minimal heating efficiency compared to gas inserts. While they produce radiant heat, most of the heat generated by gas logs escapes up the chimney rather than circulating into the room.
    • Gas Inserts: Gas inserts are designed for efficient heating and can significantly increase the heating efficiency of a fireplace. The sealed combustion system of gas inserts prevents heat loss up the chimney, and many models feature built-in blowers to circulate warm air throughout the room. Gas inserts often provide adjustable heat output and can serve as a supplemental heating source for the home.

In summary, gas logs and gas inserts offer distinct options for converting wood-burning fireplaces to gas-burning alternatives. Gas logs provide a decorative flame without significant heating efficiency, while gas inserts offer efficient heating performance and a more integrated fireplace upgrade. The choice between gas logs and gas inserts depends on factors such as desired aesthetics, heating efficiency, and installation requirements.

Scroll to Top